Stories with Pictures
Dave Gibbons, the artist of Watchmen, on a panel at San Diego Comic-Con

Dave Gibbons (35732746710) by Gage Skidmore from Peoria, AZ, United States of America, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Why Watchmen Split Critics: The Film and Series in Numbers

On screen4 min read

Watchmen has been put on screen twice, and the two attempts split opinion in opposite directions. Critics were lukewarm about Zack Snyder's 2009 film while audiences liked it better. Ten years later critics adored the HBO series while audiences cooled.

This page sets the two side by side: the scores, the money, the awards and what two reviewers wrote on the film's opening week. Scores were read on 19 November 2026. For the wider field, see the best and worst comic book films ranked by the numbers.

The comic both had to live up to

Watchmen is by the writer Alan Moore and the artist Dave Gibbons, published by DC. In 1988 it won a Hugo Award, in a category the awards list simply as Other Forms. The book works by what a page can do and a screen cannot: a reader can stop, compare two panels and turn back. Our guide to how to read a comic shows the mechanics.

The film: critics 64, audiences 71

On Rotten Tomatoes 193 of 301 reviews of the film are positive, a score of 64 per cent, and the audience score is 71. Metacritic's average is lower, 56 out of 100 from 39 reviews. The critics' consensus on Rotten Tomatoes names both sides of the argument in one sentence: gritty, visually striking and faithful, but with a narrative structure that may be hard for viewers who do not know the book.

The opening-week reviews show the split. Roger Ebert called it "a compelling visceral film" and admitted he was not sure he had understood all of it, only that the experience was powerful; he planned to see it again. Peter Bradshaw in the Guardian found a deranged epic that was "probably more flaw than masterpiece", with dull moments beside inspired ones, though he granted that there was something exhilarating in its sheer madness. One critic was moved without following everything. The other followed it and was only half persuaded.

What the film shows

Both reviews describe the same strange America. It is 1985 and Richard Nixon is still president, popular after an American victory in Vietnam that was won, Bradshaw explains, by Dr Manhattan, a blue superbeing who can bend nature to his will. Around him are masked adventurers with no powers at all. Ebert's reading is that the film faces a paradox comics had always carried: the heroes are only human, and can be in one place at a time. He judged it rich enough to be seen more than once.

The money

Box Office Mojo lists a budget of $130 million and a running time of 2 hours 42 minutes. The film opened to $55.2 million in the United States and Canada and finished there with $107.5 million, so its first weekend was more than half of its whole domestic run. With $77.9 million from other countries the worldwide total was $185.4 million, about 1.4 times the budget.

The series: critics 96, audiences 57

HBO's Watchmen, created by Damon Lindelof, began on 20 October 2019. It does not film the book. Its story is set in Tulsa, Oklahoma, 34 years after the original. After a white supremacist attack on the city's police, the synopsis runs, laws let officers hide their identities behind masks, and one of them, Angela Abar, takes on a masked identity of her own.

Critics responded almost as one: 115 of 119 reviews on Rotten Tomatoes are positive, 96 per cent. The audience score is 57, lower than the film's. The Television Academy lists 26 Emmy nominations and 11 wins for it in 2020, among them Outstanding Limited Series. It streams on HBO Max.

Film, 2009Series, 2019
Critics, Rotten Tomatoes64% (193 of 301 reviews)96% (115 of 119 reviews)
Audience, Rotten Tomatoes71%57%
Metacritic56 from 39 reviewsnot read for this page
ApproachThe book's story, closely followedA new story 34 years later
Honoursnone listed in our sources11 Emmys from 26 nominations
Money$185.4m worldwide on a $130m budgetnot applicable

What the split says about adapting a comic

The film kept the book's plot and look, and the reviews turn on exactly that: praise for fidelity, doubt about whether a newcomer can follow it. The series kept the book's world and questions and invented the rest, and critics rewarded the invention while part of the audience did not.

Our verdict: copying a great comic panel for panel earns the loyalty of its readers and little else, because the comic's effects belong to the page. The screen version that critics remember is the one that asked what the book was about and answered in its own medium.

If you have seen neither, the critics' consensus on the film is the practical advice: it is hard going without the book. Read the comic first, then the film as an illustration of it, then the series as an argument with it. For another book that critics outside comics took seriously, see Maus and the graphic novel.

Try Three Tonnes of Gold: the Brink's-Mat Robbery

Six men came for the safes and left with three tonnes of gold. The full story of the 1983 Brink's-Mat robbery, Britain's biggest gold robbery, told in pictures. Play it as a case file or read it as a story.

Start

Sources and further reading

Pages we opened when writing this article, last checked 19 November 2026. They open in a new tab, and we are not responsible for what other sites publish.

This article was drafted with the help of AI and read by a person at Picnic Player, our publisher, before it was published. Automated checks also confirmed that every listed source was opened and every picture is credited. Spotted a mistake? Write to [email protected].